Cookie Policy

RALMIXRALMIX
Journal Parents and Children

Why Good Grades Don't Always Mean Good Learning

Three students with the same grade may understand the material differently. How parents test understanding, transfer of knowledge and independence

Parents and Children illustration

Contents

  1. Student A: Understand the system
  2. Student B - perfectly memorized the pattern
  3. Student B - can get grades
  4. Five checks without additional checks
  5. What a mark measures and what can not measure
  6. Questions that give more information than “What did you get?”
  7. When assessments are important
  8. Mini-audit in 15 minutes
  9. What to develop next to assessments

Three students get an A for the same test. The result is one, the learning process is three completely different stories.

Student A: Understand the system

It solves a familiar problem, explains the principle, and rebuilds itself if the condition is slightly changed.

Student B - perfectly memorized the pattern

While the task is similar to training, the result is high. An unfamiliar format dramatically reduces confidence.

Student B - can get grades

He understands the requirements of a particular teacher well and optimizes efforts for the control. This is a useful skill, but it is not identical with deep understanding.

Five checks without additional checks

  1. Explain:Tell the subject to a person without preparation.
  2. Invent:Create your own example.
  3. Find the mistake:Discuss the wrong decision.
  4. Postpone:Apply the principle to a new situation.
  5. Remember later:Check the knowledge after a pause.

What a mark measures and what can not measure

It might reflect.Maybe not.
Performing a specific taskSustainability of knowledge in a month
Knowledge of formatTransition to a new situation
Carefulness.Depth of understanding
PreparationSelf-sufficiency

Questions that give more information than “What did you get?”

  • What's clearer today?
  • Where was it difficult?
  • How would you explain the subject to me?
  • What will change if the condition of the task is changed?
  • What mistake do you see now?

When assessments are important

In the real education system, they can affect admission, reporting, and access to programs. The problem does not begin with the existence of grades, but with turning a single digit into a single indicator of learning.

Mini-audit in 15 minutes

Step.What to watch
ExplanationConnectivity
A new exampleFlexibility
Mistake.Understanding the principle
Repeat a week laterSustainable

What to develop next to assessments

  • independence;
  • curiosity;
  • Ability to ask questions;
  • Ability to recognize misunderstanding;
  • transfer of knowledge.

A good assessment is a nice signal. The ability to explain, apply, and preserve knowledge is much stronger.

What to read and do next

Cookie settings